Home › Blog › Work & Pay
Hourly vs Salary: Which Pays More?
When a job offer says "$25 an hour" and another says "$52,000 a year", which is better? On paper they are the same. In real life, they can pay very differently depending on your hours, overtime, benefits and job security. Here is how to compare them fairly.
Want the number right now? Use the Hourly to Salary Calculator, it is free and nothing you type leaves your device.
Step 1: convert both to the same unit
A standard full-time year has about 2,080 hours (40 hours × 52 weeks).
- $25 an hour × 2,080 = $52,000 a year.
- $52,000 ÷ 2,080 = $25 an hour.
That assumes paid time off is included and you work 40 hours every week. Use the Hourly to Salary Calculator or the Salary to Hourly Calculator to run your own numbers.
Step 2: add overtime
Under US federal law (the Fair Labor Standards Act), most hourly workers who are non-exempt must be paid at least 1.5 times their regular rate for hours over 40 in a workweek. Some states have additional rules, such as daily overtime. See overtime rules by state.
Suppose you work 45 hours in a week:
- Hourly at $25: 40 × $25 = $1,000, plus 5 × ($25 × 1.5 = $37.50) = $187.50. Total: $1,187.50.
- Salaried at $52,000: $52,000 ÷ 52 = $1,000 for the week, no matter how many hours.
If you worked 50 hours on salary, your effective rate is $1,000 ÷ 50 = $20 an hour. The longer the hours, the more the salary's hourly value drops.
Many salaried workers are legally exempt from overtime, but being paid a salary alone does not make you exempt. The job duties and the pay level also have to meet legal tests. If you are not sure, check with the Department of Labor's Fair Labor Standards Act information or ask an employment professional.
Step 3: compare benefits
Pay is not the only part of the offer. Compare:
- Paid time off and holidays. Salaried roles often include paid leave. Some hourly jobs do not, which means a week off costs you a week of pay.
- Health insurance and the share you pay. The employer's contribution can be worth thousands of dollars a year.
- Retirement contributions or matching.
- Predictability. A salary gives the same paycheck each period. Hourly pay can vary with scheduled hours.
- Flexibility. Some hourly jobs let you pick up extra shifts. Some salaried jobs allow remote work or flexible schedules.
To compare two offers, add the dollar value of each benefit to the base pay and then divide by the hours you expect to work.
When hourly tends to win
- You can work extra hours and want to be paid for every one.
- The salary is close to the hourly equivalent and the job often runs over 40 hours.
- You want overtime pay or shift differentials for nights and weekends.
When salary tends to win
- You value stable income and predictable budgeting.
- You get paid time off that you will use.
- The role has growth potential and bonuses.
- Your hours are steady or under 40, so you are paid for the full week regardless.
A simple comparison table
| Question | Hourly | Salary |
|---|---|---|
| Overtime pay | Usually, if non-exempt | Usually not, if exempt |
| Paycheck stability | Varies with hours | Same each period |
| Paid for short weeks | Only hours worked | Typically full pay |
| Effective rate on long weeks | Rises with overtime | Falls as hours rise |
| Benefits | Varies by employer | Often more complete, varies by employer |
How to decide
- Convert both offers to the same unit.
- Estimate your real hours, including commuting or unpaid prep if relevant.
- Add overtime for the hourly job.
- Add the dollar value of benefits to both.
- Compare take-home pay, not just gross. See gross pay vs net pay.
Frequently asked questions
Is hourly or salary better?
Neither is better for everyone. Hourly pays more when you work a lot of overtime. Salary is better when you want stability and strong benefits.
How do I convert hourly to salary?
Multiply your hourly wage by 2,080 for a full-time year. $20 an hour is $41,600 a year before taxes.
Do salaried employees get overtime?
Some do and some do not. It depends on whether the job is exempt or non-exempt under the law, which depends on duties and pay level, not only on being paid a salary.
Which has better take-home pay?
Compare after-tax pay. Both are taxed under the same rules, but overtime and benefits change your total.
Related calculators
- Hourly to Salary CalculatorHourly wage to yearly and monthly pay
- Salary to Hourly CalculatorYearly salary to an hourly wage
- Overtime Pay CalculatorPay with time-and-a-half or double time
Guides on this topic
Keep reading
- How to Ask for a Raise: A Simple Plan Backed by MathWork & Pay · 4 min read
- Gross Pay vs Net Pay: Why Your Paycheck Is Smaller Than You ExpectedWork & Pay · 4 min read
- Side Hustle Math: How to Know If It's Really Worth Your TimeWork & Pay · 4 min read
Browse the whole blog, all calculators or all guides.
This article is general information, not financial, tax, legal, medical or religious advice. Numbers in examples are illustrations, so check your own situation or ask a qualified professional. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.